74 LR One Question 21
- « 74 LR One Question 20
- 2766 of 3815
- 74 LR One Question 22 »
Comments


Permalink Submitted by majorgeneraldave on Jul 28 2020
Huh. I'm not seeing any relationship between (A) and the argument. So let's try this; what did you find explanatory about (A)?

Permalink Submitted by gusi_lulu on Jul 30 2020
I thought that maybe the fact that the other group was more inclined to obey the comand would be more obedient and it is not because of the treat.

Permalink Submitted by majorgeneraldave on Jul 31 2020
I think my biggest problem with (A) is that it doesn't tell us which group those dogs were in: were the dogs in (A) the dogs who got treats, or not? Because if they got treats and were more inclined to obey, that might constitute an alternate explanation of the obeying dogs.
But if (A)'s dogs were in the group that didn't get treats in the study, then (A) offers no explanatory power at all.